Four decisions from the Bowl Game sideline

A play call can be reasonable in one situation and expensive in the next. These worked examples use this arcade game’s yardage distributions, kicking rates and clock rules. You choose the calls for both teams, so the examples follow the side with the ball.

Calculations checked November 12, 2026. The conversion rates below count a first down or touchdown on that single call, in an open-field situation with the listed distance to gain. They include the chance of avoiding a fumble, sack or interception. The figures describe this game’s simulation.

The conversion table

Chance of gaining at least the required yards on one play
Yards neededRunShort passDeep pass
172.50%60.00%34.00%
355.84%60.00%34.00%
722.51%52.50%34.00%
105.85%39.00%34.00%
153.90%11.25%34.00%

Runs first face a 2.5% fumble risk. After avoiding it, 94% of runs gain an integer from −2 through 8, and 6% gain 10 through 24. Short completions add 3–12 air yards to 0–7 yards after the catch. Deep completions add 15–35 air yards to 0–10 after the catch. The table enumerates those equally likely yardage combinations.

1. Fourth and one at your own 20, protecting a lead

Say you lead by three with two minutes remaining. A run converts fourth and one 72.50% of the time. That is a strong chance of extending the drive, but it also leaves a 27.50% chance of losing possession through a fumble or a gain below one yard.

Field position makes that failure costly. A stopped run hands the other team the ball around your own 20, within immediate scoring range. A punt from the same position sends the ball 40–59 yards before a 0–14 yard return. In this situation there is no touchback, and the receiving team starts between its own 21 and the opponent’s 46: 21–54 yards from its own goal line. Averaged over the equally likely combinations, it starts at its own 37.5.

A punt therefore buys field position while surrendering the ball. Going for it buys a chance to retain possession while risking a short field. Your lead, remaining time and willingness to take that failure determine the choice. The one-play conversion percentage does not settle it.

2. Fourth and ten at the opponent’s 38, needing three

The game measures a kick as the yards to the goal line plus seven. From the opponent’s 38, that is a 45-yard attempt with a 78% make rate. It yields 2.34 expected immediate points.

For a first down on this play, a short pass succeeds 39% of the time and a deep pass 34%. That may look backward. Every deep completion gains enough, but only 34% of calls complete. Short passes complete 60% of the time, and 52 of their 80 equally likely completed-yardage combinations gain ten or more. Multiplying 60% by 52/80 gives 39%.

If you trail by two late, the kick can put you ahead. If you trail by four, a successful kick still leaves you behind. A conversion could extend a touchdown drive, so comparing 2.34 expected kicking points directly with 39% conversion would mix different outcomes. One is an immediate score and the other preserves a future scoring opportunity.

3. Third and fifteen with forty seconds left

A deep pass converts fifteen yards on 34% of calls. A short pass converts on 11.25%, because only the longest short completions reach fifteen. For this distance, the deeper throw offers a much better chance of immediately moving the chains.

There is still a clock tradeoff. In this simulation an ordinary incomplete pass consumes 5–9 seconds, a sack consumes 24–35, and most completed passes consume 27–39. With forty seconds remaining, a sack usually leaves 5–16 seconds. A non-scoring completion usually leaves only 1–13. A touchdown uses a different 18–27 second clock rule.

The deep call also carries a 12% sack risk and a 7% interception risk, compared with 8% and 4% for the short call. Choose it because the situation calls for the available yardage, and budget for the clock that follows. The game has no timeout control to rescue a plan that assumes every completion leaves another comfortable snap.

4. A touchdown leaves you two points behind

Before the conversion, you trail by two. The extra-point kick succeeds 95% of the time and earns one point. Even a successful kick leaves you one point behind. The two-point attempt succeeds 45% of the time and can tie the game.

Across unrelated touchdowns, the kick has the higher immediate average of 0.95 points, compared with 0.90 for going for two. In this situation, the 0.05-point difference in average is less relevant than the score you need on this one. If there is time for another possession, consider that too. If the touchdown has already ended the game clock, the final-whistle state can prevent another conversion call, so this decision needs time still available.

How to reproduce and use the calculations

The yardage table comes from enumerating the game’s discrete outcomes. The study also samples 100,000 plays from each actual play-call function as a cross-check, failing if the observed distribution materially disagrees. Kicking rates are read from the same function the game uses. The downloadable study data records source fingerprints and the check date.

These calculations stop at the immediate result of a play or kick. They do not simulate the rest of the match, future coaching choices or a win-probability model. The examples are a way to reason about the rules you can see.

Try the Bowl Game, check the complete rules, or use the kicking calculator and strategy overview. More experiments are collected in the guides library.